The Erotic Christ And Christianity's Forbidden Sexual Undercurrents

The Christ Image

I entered this discussion with some trepidation. Jesus means a lot of different things to a lot of different people. And after the cursory investigation that lead to this essay, I don’t purport my words to hold any fundamental truths about Christ, his existence, or his life. Rather my essay focuses on the 2000 years of images left by followers of Christ and more specifically how the idea of his crucifixion has left us with an iconographic legacy that has inevitably crossed over (no pun intended) into our erotic consciousness.


Fig 1. Franciscan nun

The crucifixion cross like the Saint Andrews cross that fills our dungeons now fill our visual erotic vocabulary, not as some kind of appropriation of religion or spirituality but more as an on-going and sometimes symbolic element of bondage and restraint that has now morphed from being an implement of torture to one of pleasure through our modern day BDSM play. Ultimately the crucifix occupies its own place in the art we make now. But the crucifixion and the idea of an erotic Christ goes deeper than that. Let’s start with some other interesting connections between what we consider eroticism and the (holy) cross.

Erotic Christ : A Quick Overview From Christian Mysticism to Tantric Jesus

The very term and concept of the "Erotic Christ" has a surprisingly long history in which to place contemporary iterations of Christ and the crucifixion. It spans from pre Christian dogma through medieval Christian mysticism, art history, queer theology, and modern alternative spirituality. Rather than simply showing a literal sexual biography of Jesus, it shows how sensuality, desire, the human body, and eroticism have always intersected with the divine or the spiritual. In various mystical traditions, the intense longing of the human soul for God has often been expressed through deeply passionate, romantic, and occasionally erotic language: The idea of a human manifestation of that connection through the idea of a tortured soul on earth was a natural evolution. But here is a quick breakdown of some of the various elements that has made up the idea of Erotic Christ.

Even before Christ’s birth, The Song of Songs, a poetic book of the Hebrew Bible and ascribed to King Solomon,(900 BCE) was filled with explicit descriptions of physical touch, bodies, and longing and was traditionally interpreted by Christian theologians and monks as the blueprint for the soul's union with God. 

In later medieval times Christian mystics like Mathilde of Magdeburg and Saint John of the Cross also wrote rapturous, intimate poetry describing the soul entering the bridal chamber of Christ. Late medieval and Renaissance art frequently depicted the body of Christ with a heightened physical presence, emphasizing his corporeal reality, vulnerability, and humanity. Artists like Maerten van Heemskerck and Lucas Cranach painted the Man of Sorrows or the Crucifixion with muscular, near-naked forms and drapery that explicitly drew the viewer's attention to the anatomical and reproductive body of Christ.These portrayals aimed to underline the full incarnation, or the belief that God genuinely took on fragile, bleeding, human flesh

In Baroque times, Spanish mystic Saint Theresa of Avila, a follower of Saint John of the Cross was the subject of Lorenzo Bernini’s “ Saint Theresa in Ecstasy”. The case of Bernini’s Saint Theresa is a good example of the ambiguity between religious and erotic ecstasy. Many scholars have argued that there are sexual implications in the work. It has been called "decidedly risqué, the most astounding peep show in art as well as the grossest and most offensive example of Baroque art. It has been argued that its popularity had too much do with sex. It was also been noted that by placing the sculpture in a somewhat theatrical setting, Bernini was intentionally turning a private (erotic?) moment into a public spectacle. Some Victorian critics even wanted it destroyed. But art historian Simon Scharma argued that sometimes: "Critics and scholars tie themselves in knots, trying to avoid stating the obvious." But the sculpture remains one of our most eloquent examples of that thin line between religious rapture and erotic excitement.


Fig 2. Lorenzo Bernini, The Ecstasy of Saint Theresa


Fig 3. Lorenzo Bernini, The Ecstasy of Saint Theresa

More recently, in his book Tantric Jesus : The Erotic Heart of Early Christianity, Episcopalian priest James Hughes Reho offered a re-articulation of spiritual practice in an engrossing history of the connection between the erotic and the spiritual.. Bringing together tantric Hinduism alongside writings by Christian church fathers, he shows how the body-shaming, change-fearing goals of contemporary Christianity run counter to its original message. Reho challenges the popular notion of tantra as exotic sexual mastery while showing how eroticism can be part of holiness and the search for a higher connection to God.  


Fig 4. Tantric Jesus by James Reho

Finally, we must also note that traditional mainstream Christian denominations generally continue to maintain a view of Jesus as celibate and view modern sexualized or eroticized re-readings as a distortion of scripture. Conversely, some contemporary liturgical events such as progressive or pride-themed services have invoked the language of an "erotic Christ" to welcome LGBTQ+ communities into sacred spaces. Scholars and activists such as Kittredge Cherry use the "erotic Christ" to reclaim the physical body from centuries of body-shaming or ascetic theology, viewing marginalized and queer physical experiences as valid manifestations of divine or spiritual-erotic encounter.

A Quick But Important Sidebar: A Little Historical Background On the Crucifix

Crucifixion, it must be noted was not specific to Jesus Christ of course. Hanging a man on a cross was a common means of punishment. In 73 BC for instance, years before Christ, an escaped Thracian gladiator named Spartacus, broke out of a gladiatorial training school. in Capua with about 70 to 78 other gladiators using kitchen tools and seized weapons. The rebellion was eventually put down by the Roman army but to deter future uprisings, Roman general Marcus Crassus captured thousands of survivors and ordered 6,000 of them crucified along the Appian Way between Rome and Capua, with the remaining fleeing remnants intercepted and killed.


Fig. 5  Spartacus Rebellion, 97 BC

Eroticism As Part of Religious Art 

And it’s not just in our contemporary manifestations using the crucifix that we find ambiguity between religious fervor and erotic meaning. There is ample evidence to suggest that religion itself was a kind of erotic experience for many and that goes back to before Jesus. There are many examples of religious art that seem to imply that the experience of worship is a kind of “letting go”, a  release comparable to the pleasure many obtain through bondage, restraint, and pain, not to mention orgasm. The practices of many religious orders resemble kink practices of today.

Aside from my appreciation for the work of Maerten van Heemskerck and Lucas Cranach, it was while apprehending an anonymous Crucifixion scene in a Flemish painting now part of the Phoebus Collection, that it became clear to me that erotic pleasure in religious art was not just something that we applied in a kind of post-modern hindsight but that it was highly likely that erotic pleasure was a literal part of religious art. It was quite possible that religion and eroticism had only been separated at some later point by the Christian Church.

The depiction of the crucifixion in the Flemish painting filled with symbolic objects, shows a female, (Mother Mary? Mary Magdalen?) stroking the cross. The painting is too allegorical to dismiss the cloth as being without meaning. The cloth that covers Jesus’ loins look like an ejaculation and the red cloth around the woman has some meaning such as blood or menstrual fluid. This is a consummation the relationship between this woman and Christ on the cross. The scene of the snake and the ladder in the background, symbols of good and evil, are made secondary to sexually charged scene in the foreground. It is difficult to dismiss that eroticism and the worship of Christ evolved side by side.


Fig 6 Man of Sorrows, Maerten van Heemskerck. 1532


Fig 7. Flemish Master, Phoebus Collection, c1550

Modern Art: The 19th and 20th century

In the 19th century and into the 20th the idea of the crucifixion continued to occupy a space in art whether sacred or profane. French painter William Bouguereau continued the tradition of painting Christ as a human being in a highly realistic and sensual way.

Other artists such as Norman Lindsay in Australia or Symbolist Félicien Rops in Belgium appropriated the crucifixion scene in a more erotic sense and began the idea of transposing a female figure on the cross. Lindsay’s “Crucified Venus” turns the idea of holiness on its head by positing values such as beauty or aesthetics as being crucified.

Rops’ “The temptation of Saint Anthony” places religious obedience or symbolic meaning in direct opposition to eroticism or the temptations of the flesh. These are interesting counterpoints to the idea that representations of the crucifixion can contain an erotic sub text. But the idea of crucifixion evolved to have multiple meanings in art with religious fervor being only one.


Fig 8  Flagellation of Christ, William Bouguereau, 1880


Fig 9  Norman Lindsay, Venus Crucified , 1912


Fig 10 Felicien Rops, Temptation of Saint Anthony, 1884

In Premium you can check out the complete essay including the case of Andres Serrano (and his notorious "Piss Christ" piece), other contemporary erotic artists, the use of the "crucifix" theme by Warsaw based Shibari rope rigger Agloval Bremervo, thoughts on shock film The Devils from 1971,  and MORE....!!

Click HERE for a profound treatise by the author about the dirty secrets behind the chastity belt

Let us know your thoughts about this article in the comment box below...!!