PHOTOGRAPHY VS. PORNOGRAPHY — VOL. X. THE ULTIMATE HALL OF FAME: An Erotic Shamans' Pantheon (Part 1)
Editor's Note: A Love Letter With a Shadow
This last instalment was meant to be a corollary to our journey through the history of photography and pornography, a love letter to the famous and less famous artists who have used eroticism as a language of artistic expression, rebellion, imagination and self-discovery.
1. Alfred Stieglitz, Georgia O'Keeffe—Torso, 1931 gelatin silver print part of a composite portrait of over 300 images taken of his wife between 1917 and 1937
2. Vulva, 2014 Photography by Michal Jedrak via Saatchi Art
But a final chapter about erotic freedom cannot simply hand out medals, raise a glass to the beautiful troublemakers and close the gallery doors. There are shadows in this exhibition, and pretending otherwise would make the celebration rather less interesting.
3/4 Erotos series, 1993 Gelatin Silver Print by Nobuyoshi Araki, monochromatic close-ups via Ocula / Nobuyoshi Araki, Erotos, 1993 Gelatin silver print via Artsy
Terence, the Roman playwright, offered a useful starting point more than two thousand years ago: Homo sum: humani nihil a me alienum puto — “I am human, and nothing human is alien to me.”
5. Untitled, The Look, Erotos series 1993 Gelatin Silver Print by Nobuyoshi Araki via Artsy
The line has travelled through centuries of arguments about empathy, morality and our responsibility towards others. It is an especially useful thought when discussing sexuality, because few subjects reveal our capacity for contradiction quite so efficiently.
We are fascinated by bodies, yet anxious about what they might mean; we consume erotic imagery while policing the people who create it; we preach restraint while finding endless new ways to package temptation.
6/7 Anonimo - Untitled (Erotic scene), c.1900s-1920s / Art-Porn-Bliss by Anne Lomberg, German poet and film photographer. In 2017 she started shooting erotic photography
The history of erotic photography is, among other things, a history of these contradictions. And if this series has taught us anything, it is that the camera has always had a dirty mind — although the institutions that decide which photographs deserve a place on the gallery wall have hardly been innocent bystanders.
Our ultimate hall of fame, then, needs room for beauty, provocation, pleasure and uncomfortable questions.
8/9 Eikoh Hosoe, Embrace#47, 1970 Silver gelatin print via Artsy / Eikoh Hosoe, Embrace #11, 1969 Gelatin silver print on baryta paper via Artsy
It also needs to acknowledge the difference between liberating the body and exploiting it, between challenging a taboo and disguising an abuse of power as artistic freedom.
Because the erotic imagination deserves better than censorship. It also deserves better than excuses.
THE CAMERA, THE BODY AND THE BUSINESS OF DESIRE
The painted nude had already taught Western culture how to look at an idealised body. Photography changed the rules because suddenly the body could be reproduced with an entirely different claim to reality.
The nineteenth-century erotic photograph was not Venus emerging from the sea. She was a woman who had stood in front of a camera. That difference was revolutionary.
10/11 Vintage photograph by Guglielmo Marconi, Untitled, female nude viewed from behind. Currently held in the Harvard Art Museums / Visionaire #23, The Emperor's New Clothes, 1997 photography art book by Karl Lagerfeld
Photography democratised looking, although not necessarily the power to control what was being looked at. A nude image was no longer a unique object available only to aristocrats, wealthy collectors or visitors to an artist’s studio.
It could be printed, sold, concealed, exchanged and collected. Erotic imagery began to travel through a new economy of desire, where the photograph became a portable commodity and privacy became part of its appeal.
Some early erotic photographs were expensive enough to compete with the services of a sex worker, while collectors in the Parisian demimonde treated them as objects of private fascination.
12/13 Maryam Eisler, Wildcat Hill III (from the series Imagining Tina A Dialogue with Edward Weston) 2018 platinum print on Arches Platine paper via Sotheby's / Ziegfeld Girls Portfolio, photographs taken between 1917 and 1931 by New York photographer Alfred Cheney Johnston ©Frank Gerald Hegewald
The boundaries between respectable society and its supposedly disreputable underside were never quite as secure as their guardians would have liked. The photograph could be condemned in public and admired behind closed doors, a pattern that has proved remarkably durable.
Cinema soon joined the game. In 1896, Le Coucher de la Mariée, directed by Albert Kirchner under the name Léar, featured Louise Willy performing a striptease. It belonged to the early wave of French films exploring the commercial possibilities of watching women undress.
14. Eadweard J. Muybridge, Two Women Kissing (1887), collotype
The camera had discovered a profitable secret: desire could be reproduced. Then came postcards, cabinet photographs, pin-ups, men's magazines and increasingly specialised forms of fetish photography.
The body was organised into types, poses, categories and fantasies. Each new format offered another way of making eroticism visible while keeping it at a carefully negotiated distance from respectable public life.
Continue reading in Premium and check out the extended edition of this publication (over 4000 words + 81 pics!) including:
- Objects of Desire: the Private Ritual of Looking
- The Shadow in the Frame: Desire, Power and Consent
- The Erotic Shamans' Pantheon
- Epilogue: Nothing Human Is Alien To Me
Click HERE for volume I of the PHOTOGRAPHY OR PORNOGRAPHY? -series titled "The Camera Discovers Desire"
Let us know your thoughts about the above article in the comment box below...!!